Live Free Software logo: mountains and a pine tree under a crescent LiveFreeSoftware Free Trial
0%

How to Use Customer Reviews to Win More New Customers

By Giles CollinsPublished November 15, 2026Updated November 15, 20266 min read

Short answer

Put real reviews where people make up their minds: on your Google Business Profile, next to your phone number and booking button, and on each service page. Show them honestly with names and a link to the source, reply to them, and keep new ones coming, because most people look for reviews from the last few months.

Ninety-seven percent. That's the share of US consumers who read reviews for local businesses, according to BrightLocal's 2026 survey of 1,002 adults. Forty-one percent said they always read them, up from 29% a year earlier.

So your reviews are already doing sales work, whether you planned it or not. The question is whether people actually see the good ones at the moment they're deciding. Below I'll cover where to show your reviews, how to show them honestly and how to keep new ones coming. If your Google profile isn't set up yet, start with our Google Business Profile setup, since that's where most people will see your reviews first.

What do people check before they call?

The same survey paints a pretty clear picture:

  • How recent the reviews are. 74% look for reviews from the last three months.
  • How many there are. 47% won't use a business with fewer than 20 reviews.
  • The star rating. 68% want four stars or more, and 31% now want 4.5 or higher.
  • Whether the owner replies. 89% expect owners to respond.

Look at your own profile with that list in mind. If your newest review is from 2024 and you have 11 in total, a new customer is going to hesitate, even if every one of them is glowing.

Where do reviews do the most work?

Wherever someone is about to make a decision. For a local business, that usually means three places.

Your Google Business Profile

This is often the first thing people see when they search for your service. A complete profile with recent reviews and replies does more for you than anything else on this list. Google also lists review count and rating among the things that affect local ranking, in its help page on local results, which is why local SEO and reviews go hand in hand.

Don't ignore the other maps, though. In the same BrightLocal survey, the share of people using Apple Maps for reviews nearly doubled, from 14% to 27%, while Google's share dropped from 83% to 71%. Google is still the big one, but it's worth claiming your Apple listing too.

Your website

People who find you on Google often click through to your site before they call. If your reviews vanish the moment they land on your homepage, you've lost your best argument.

Your follow-ups

A quote, an estimate or a "thanks for reaching out" email is a good spot for one short review from a past customer. Someone comparing three quotes will notice which business has proof.

How should you show reviews on your website?

Put them close to the decision: next to your phone number, near your "Book now" button and on the page for each service.

  • Match the review to the page. A review that mentions a deck repair belongs on your deck page as well as your homepage.
  • Show names the way they appear on the review site, and link back to the original so people can check it.
  • Use a review widget if you can. The CRM on our Complete Platform includes a website widget that shows your real reviews and updates on its own, so your site never gets stuck on reviews from two years ago.
  • Never edit a customer's words to sound better. Trimming a long review is okay. Changing what it says isn't.

Our review generation tools include the widget, a review inbox and printable QR codes, and the reviews how-to guide walks through setting them up.

Prices as of November 2026, from our plans and pricing page: the review widget and review requests come with the Complete Platform at $300 a month. Text and email requests are billed by use on top of the plan. Rates can change with notice.

Probably not for your own business, so be wary of anyone who promises it. Google's review snippet guidelines say pages about a local business or other organization aren't eligible for star snippets when the business controls the reviews about itself, and that includes reviews shown through a widget.

Your stars still show on your Google Business Profile, which is where they matter most. It's also why we don't put review ratings in the structured data of our own pages.

Should you only show five-star reviews?

For a "What customers say" strip on your homepage, picking favorites is normal. But the FTC has warned that marketing with reviews that aren't typical of your customers could mislead people. If your average is 4.3, don't build a page that suggests every single customer gave you five stars.

If your site has a spot where customers post reviews themselves, keep the critical ones visible. The FTC treats cutting reviews only because they're unfavorable as potentially deceptive. Our article on review rules that can get you in trouble explains the rest.

The upside is that a few less-than-perfect reviews hurt less than people fear. Google's own tips point out that a mix of positive and negative feedback can come across as more trustworthy.

How do your replies win customers?

Replies are the one part of your reviews you get to write yourself. Think of each one as a tiny ad for how you treat people.

In BrightLocal's survey, four out of five people said they'd likely pick a business that answers every review. A short thank-you under a five-star review shows you notice. A calm, helpful answer under a one-star review shows what happens when something goes wrong, which is exactly what a nervous new customer wants to know. We wrote a whole article on how to respond to a negative review, with examples.

How do you keep fresh reviews coming in?

Since recent reviews matter so much, a one-time push isn't enough. You need a habit: ask every customer, every time, right after the job. Our guide on asking customers for reviews has wording for in person, text and email.

This is where automation earns its keep. A review request that goes out on its own whenever a job is marked done means you never have to remember. Our workflow automation handles the timing, and you write the message once.

Can reviews help you show up in AI answers?

They likely play a part. BrightLocal found that 45% of consumers used ChatGPT or another AI tool for local recommendations in 2026, up from 6% the year before, and 82% said they read AI-written review summaries. Nobody outside those companies knows exactly how their tools pick businesses. But a summary can only work with the reviews that exist, so a steady supply of recent, detailed ones gives it more good things to say about you.

Can you use reviews in ads and social posts?

Yes, with a little care. A screenshot of a great review makes a solid social post. A few tips:

  • Ask the customer before you use their name or photo in a paid ad. Most people say yes, and asking avoids surprises.
  • Don't change their words, and don't crop out the part where they mention a problem you fixed.
  • Once a review shows up in an ad, the FTC treats it as a testimonial, so normal advertising rules apply.

What can you do this week?

You don't need a full website rebuild to put your reviews to work. Here's a short list you can get through in an afternoon or two:

  1. Reply to every Google review from the last few months that doesn't have a reply yet.
  2. Pick three strong, specific reviews and add one to your homepage, one to your busiest service page and one to your contact page.
  3. Add a short review line to the email you send with quotes or estimates.
  4. Claim or check your Apple Maps listing so your details match your Google profile.
  5. Start asking every customer, starting with the next job you finish.

None of these cost anything but time, and they put your best proof in front of people right when they're deciding.

Common mistakes

  • Tucking reviews away on a separate "Testimonials" page that nobody clicks.
  • Copying reviews onto the site by hand once and never updating them.
  • Showing reviews without names or links, which makes them look made up.
  • Paying for a service that promises review stars in Google search results.
  • Polishing the website and forgetting the Google profile.

When should you hold off on this?

If you only have a handful of reviews, showing them off isn't your biggest job yet. Put your energy into asking first, then come back to this once you have a steady flow. And if you work in health care or another field with privacy rules, get written permission before you feature a patient's or client's review anywhere you control, and check your profession's rules on testimonials. This isn't legal advice.

Want to see how your site stacks up first? Work through our Local SEO Checklist, which covers your profile and reviews along with the rest.

FAQ

Showing reviews questions.

What owners ask once the reviews start coming in.

Want a second opinion?

Send us your website and we'll suggest where your reviews would do the most good.

Contact us

How many reviews do I need?

There's no magic number, but in BrightLocal's 2026 survey almost half of consumers said fewer than 20 reviews was a dealbreaker. Getting past 20, then adding new ones every month, is a good first goal.

Do I need a perfect 5.0 rating?

No. Most people want four stars or more, and a few honest, less-than-perfect reviews can make the good ones easier to believe.

Can I put my Google reviews on my website?

Yes. A review widget is the easiest way, since it pulls in your real reviews and links to the source. If you quote one by hand, keep the wording exact and link to the original.

How often should I update the reviews on my site?

A widget updates itself. If you add reviews by hand, refresh them at least every few months so visitors see recent ones.

See all FAQs

About the author.

Giles Collins, founder of Live Free Software

Giles Collins

Giles founded Live Free Software in Manchester, NH, in 2026. Before that he worked in the music industry and ran a pressure washing business, so he writes from the owner's side of the counter.

Connect on LinkedIn

Want your reviews working harder?

Try every tool free for 5 days, or book a call and we'll look at where your reviews could show up.