Live Free Software logo: mountains and a pine tree under a crescent LiveFreeSoftware Free Trial
0%

Online Review Rules That Can Get Your Business in Trouble

By Giles CollinsPublished November 15, 2026Updated November 15, 20266 min read

Short answer

Don't reward people for reviews, don't ask only happy customers, don't post or buy reviews, and don't threaten anyone over an honest one. Google can remove reviews that break its rules, and the FTC can seek fines of up to $53,088 per violation for knowing violations of its review rule. Ask every customer the same way and you're on solid ground.

Most review trouble starts with a good idea. "Let's give 10% off to anyone who leaves us a review!" sounds friendly and generous. It also breaks Google's rules, and depending on the wording, it can run into federal law as well.

Review rules aren't hard, but they're spread across Google's policies, Yelp's guidelines and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), and they don't all say the same thing. I pulled them together here in plain English, with a link to every source. One honest note before we start: this isn't legal advice, so ask a lawyer about your own situation. If you want a way of asking that's built to follow the rules, that's how we set up our review generation tools: one request, sent to every customer, with no reward attached.

Who makes the rules?

Mostly three groups:

  • The review sites. Google and Yelp each have their own policies, and they can remove reviews that break them.
  • The FTC. Its rule on consumer reviews and testimonials took effect October 21, 2024, and it lets courts fine businesses that knowingly break it.
  • Contract law. The Consumer Review Fairness Act says your contracts and terms can't stop customers from posting honest reviews.

Your state may have its own consumer protection laws on top of those. The safest plan is to follow the strictest rule, and for most local businesses that's Google's.

Can you give a discount or gift for a review?

Not on Google. Its Maps content policy bans offering payment, discounts, free goods or free services in exchange for a review, or for changing or removing a negative one. That covers the "10% off your next visit" sign, the free car wash for a five-star review and the raffle ticket for anyone who posts.

The FTC's rule is a bit narrower. It bans rewards that depend on the review saying something positive (or negative). The FTC's questions-and-answers page on the rule says rewards that don't depend on what the review says aren't banned by the rule itself, but they should be disclosed, and hiding them could still break the FTC Act. Since Google bans review rewards outright, the simple answer for a local business is no rewards, period.

Can you ask only your happy customers?

No. This one catches a lot of honest businesses, because it's built into some review software. It's often called review gating, and it works like this: the customer gets a "How did we do?" message. If they tap five stars, they're sent to Google. If they tap one to three, they get a private feedback form instead.

Google's policy says businesses may not selectively ask for positive reviews or discourage negative ones. The FTC's rule doesn't name this practice, but the FTC says it could still break the FTC Act, and its guide for businesses on asking for reviews tells you not to ask only the customers you expect to be positive.

The fix is simple: send the same request to everyone. Asking for private feedback as well is fine, as long as every customer still gets the same link to post a public review.

Can employees, friends or family review you?

Generally, no. Google bans reviews based on a conflict of interest, which can include current or former employees and people with business ties to you. Its policy also bans posting on a competitor's listing to drag them down. Yelp's content guidelines say you shouldn't review your own business, your employer, or a friend's or relative's business.

The FTC's rule allows reviews from company insiders only when the relationship is clearly disclosed, and it limits asking employees and their relatives for reviews. Put it together and the answer is easy: your mom can tell her friends about you, but she shouldn't post a review.

Can you buy reviews or have someone write them?

No, and this is where the biggest penalties live. The FTC's rule bans writing, buying or selling fake reviews, including reviews from people who never used your business. A business can be held responsible for purchased reviews it knew, or should have known, were fake.

Be wary of marketing companies that promise "50 five-star reviews in 30 days." Nobody can honestly promise a number, because real reviews come from real customers. If a company pads your profile with fake ones, your business is the one on the hook.

Can you threaten someone over a bad review?

No. The FTC's rule bans using unfounded legal threats, physical threats, intimidation or certain false public accusations to stop a review or get one taken down. Firing off "remove it or I'll sue" over an honest one-star review is exactly what it targets.

Contracts count too. Under the Consumer Review Fairness Act, your estimates, contracts and online terms can't include clauses that stop customers from posting honest reviews, charge them a fee for reviewing or claim ownership of what they write. The FTC's guide to that law says even a clause you never enforce can get you in trouble. Its first cases under the law, in 2019, involved an HVAC company, a flooring company and a horseback riding business. If your contract template has a "non-disparagement" clause, have it checked.

You can still report reviews that break a site's rules, like spam or fake reviews. Just don't use the report button to bury honest criticism. The FTC's guide warns against that, too.

Can you hide bad reviews on your own website?

It depends on how you show them. If your website has a section where customers post reviews, the FTC says leaving out reviews just because they're negative can be deceptive. Sorting by most helpful is fine.

Testimonials you hand-pick for a sales page are treated differently, but the FTC still warns that featuring reviews that don't reflect most customers' experience could be deceptive. Our article on turning reviews into new customers covers how to show reviews honestly.

What about Yelp?

Yelp is stricter than Google. Its guidelines say businesses should never ask customers to write reviews at all. So ask for Google reviews, and let Yelp reviews arrive on their own. Our guide on how to ask for reviews without feeling pushy shows a request that fits Google's rules.

What happens if you break the rules?

On Google, reviews that break the rules can be removed, and that can mean losing a lot of them at once. The FTC can take a business to court, and knowing violations of its review rule can bring civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation. In December 2025 the FTC sent warning letters to 10 companies about possible violations of the rule, according to its press release. The letters weren't findings that anyone broke the rule, but they show the FTC is paying attention.

Penalty amount as of November 2026, from the FTC's December 2025 press release. The FTC adjusts penalty amounts for inflation from time to time.

So what's the safe way to ask?

After all those don'ts, here's the good part. Asking for reviews is allowed, and doing it well is simple:

  1. Pick one moment to ask, like when a job is finished or an invoice is paid.
  2. Send every customer the same short message with your Google review link.
  3. Ask for an honest review, never a five-star one.
  4. Send one reminder at most, and leave it there.
  5. Reply to the reviews that come in, good and bad.

That's the whole system. It works for a one-person cleaning business and for a shop with ten employees, and none of it needs a reward, a filter or a quota. If you'd like it to run on its own, the CRM on our Complete Platform can send the request and the reminder automatically after each job.

A quick self-check

  • Does every customer get the same review request, happy or not?
  • Is there no reward of any kind tied to leaving a review?
  • Are staff, relatives and business partners kept off your reviews?
  • Do your contracts and terms leave customers free to post honest reviews?
  • If customers post reviews on your site, are the less glowing ones still there?

Five yeses and you're in good shape.

Common mistakes

  • Buying review software with a "happy customers only" filter switched on.
  • Running a giveaway where you enter by leaving a review.
  • Letting a marketing company post reviews on your behalf.
  • Copying a contract template from the internet without reading the fine print.
  • Setting a monthly review quota for staff with a bonus attached.

When should you talk to a lawyer?

Get real legal advice if you've received a letter from the FTC or a state attorney general, if a reviewer is threatening to sue you, or if you want to answer a review in a field with confidentiality rules like health care or law. The same goes for any plan that involves paying people who are connected to reviews in any way. This article covers the general rules as of November 2026, and rules change.

FAQ

Review rules questions.

Plain answers to the rule questions owners ask most. This isn't legal advice.

Not sure your setup is allowed?

Tell us how you ask for reviews now and we'll point out anything that looks risky.

Ask us

Is it legal to ask customers for reviews at all?

Yes. Google allows businesses to ask and even gives you a review link and QR code to share. Yelp is the exception: its guidelines say businesses shouldn't ask for reviews.

Can I hold a prize drawing for everyone who leaves a review?

Not for Google reviews. A chance to win a prize is still a reward, and Google bans rewards of any kind for posting a review.

What if a competitor leaves me a fake review?

Report it through your Business Profile. Google's policy bans posting on a competitor's listing to hurt its reputation. Reply calmly in the meantime, without accusing anyone by name.

Can I put a review sign or QR code at my counter?

Yes. A sign with your review link or QR code is a fine way to ask. Just don't pressure people to post while they're standing there.

See all FAQs

About the author.

Giles Collins, founder of Live Free Software

Giles Collins

Giles founded Live Free Software in Manchester, NH, in 2026. Before that he worked in the music industry and ran a pressure washing business, so he writes from the owner's side of the counter.

Connect on LinkedIn

Want a review process that follows the rules?

Try every tool free for 5 days, or book a call and we'll look at how you ask for reviews today.